Boat Building Forum

Find advice on all aspects of building your own kayak, canoe or any lightweight boats

Re: alternatives to wood - I don't think so.
By:Erez
Date: 8/10/2000, 5:45 pm
In Response To: alternatives to wood (Paul Wild)

Hello Paul,

When I chose to build a wood kayak I knew it's not going to be as durable as plastic, & I DID had plastic experience when I chose wood.

I have a Coho. It has hits & bangs all over it. but I don't care. It still draws attention when I pump gas. & I don't care about that either.

When I will paddle with a plastic buddy I will probably feel like you feel now, but I will hold to my initial considerations: I built it myself, it's stronger than plastic, it's stiffer than plastic, it's lighter than plastic, it's cheaper than plastic, & right now it is take-a-part the way a plastic can't be !

I think the source of the problem is the epoxy, it is softer than plastic.

soft is the opposite of hard.

weak is the opposite of strong.

don't mix this 2 characteristics.

any option suggested on previous messages that says use kevlar/carbon/this/ or that - with epoxy, will not do you any good because you will still get these scraches on the epoxy, & they will be deep enough to get to the cloth & expose its weave.

the large number of "pride" responses you got, supporting the wood kayaks, point at the inevitable answer to your question: NO ! there probably isn't a better choice. & I think it makes sense. If there was a better choice, everybody would have used it, & this bbs wasn't about wood kayaks, but about that other better way that doesn't exist yet.

think about the grinlanders/inuits/eskimos. their skins on frames where even more fragile than your wood/glass/epoxy, & they relied on it for their lifes.

I hope you feel better now... 8-)

Erez

Messages In This Thread

alternatives to wood
Paul Wild -- 8/9/2000, 8:27 pm
Re: alternatives to wood
bob -- 8/10/2000, 10:14 pm
Re: alternatives to wood
Vernon Lowery -- 8/10/2000, 9:56 pm
Idea to spruce up your alternate materails
Hafte -- 8/11/2000, 9:18 am
Re: alternatives to wood - I don't think so.
Erez -- 8/10/2000, 5:45 pm
Re: alternatives to wood
Paul G. Jacobson -- 8/10/2000, 12:36 am
Re: alternatives to wood
CommonStriped -- 8/9/2000, 10:27 pm
Re: alternatives to wood
Rob Forsell -- 8/10/2000, 8:11 am
Re: alternatives to wood
CommonStriped -- 8/10/2000, 10:36 am
Re: alternatives to wood
Rick Thomas -- 8/9/2000, 11:39 pm
Re: alternatives to wood
Jerry Siegel -- 8/9/2000, 9:42 pm
Re: alternatives to wood
Mike Scarborough -- 8/9/2000, 9:20 pm