Boat Building Forum

Find advice on all aspects of building your own kayak, canoe or any lightweight boats

Prejudices - Attach Skin OR Sew Skin??
By:mike allen --->
Date: 10/25/2000, 5:40 pm
In Response To: Best to Attach Skin OR Sew Skin?? (mike allen --->)

: Question: In the finished yak(not during bldg), what are the relative
: benefits or not of an attached skin(like the walrus w/ staples or copper
: nails) or of a sewed skin like the traditionals.

: Or when you hyponalize or urethane the traditional, does the coating soak
: thru anyway to adhere the skin to the frame.

: And in Jay Babina's yak, does the epoxy soak thru the glass and adhere the
: skin to the frame.

: What contribution to the overal strength of a skin yak is the skin - adhered
: and not. Like in a stressful situation, what breaks first.(not talking
: about rocks)

: Or which is stronger: a walrus(attached) or a traditional(not so attached)?

: any thoughts?

: -mick

I have some prejudices on this but little knowledge. And it is all a moot point if the skin adheres under normal practices anyway(well foldables). I think that if the frame breaks in an attached skin, that there is way more likely to be skin damage. And that the unattached skin allows both the frame or the skin to be stressed to their limits more readily. (I wanted to exclude this, but I bet punctures are harder w/ the tradional because the skin can move more). But those walrus truss sides look strong strong strong.

Or is this cutting hairs?

-mick

Messages In This Thread

Best to Attach Skin OR Sew Skin??
mike allen ---> -- 10/25/2000, 5:24 pm
Re: Best to Attach Skin OR Sew Skin??
Paul C -- 10/27/2000, 5:37 pm
Re: Best to Attach Skin OR Sew Skin??
Jay Babina -- 10/26/2000, 2:51 pm
Re: Best to Attach Skin OR Sew Skin??
Marty Hangarter -- 10/27/2000, 9:39 am
Re: Best to Attach Skin OR Sew Skin??
Jay Babina -- 10/27/2000, 2:36 pm
Varnished skin kayak *Pic*
Jay Babina -- 10/27/2000, 9:25 am
Re: Best to Attach Skin OR Sew Skin??
Mike Hanks -- 10/25/2000, 8:30 pm
Re: Best to Attach Skin OR Sew Skin??
Pete Strand -- 10/26/2000, 12:42 pm
More Skin Questions
mike allen ---> -- 10/26/2000, 1:45 pm
Re: More Skin Questions
Mike Hanks -- 10/27/2000, 11:29 pm
Re: More Skin Questions
mike allen ---> -- 10/30/2000, 12:08 pm
Re: More Skin Questions *Pic*
Mike Hanks -- 11/1/2000, 12:45 am
Re: More Skin Questions
Pete Strand -- 10/27/2000, 8:23 pm
Some More Skin Questions
mike allen ---> -- 10/27/2000, 9:23 pm
Prejudices - Attach Skin OR Sew Skin??
mike allen ---> -- 10/25/2000, 5:40 pm
A Statistician's Answer: It Depends
Bill Price -- 10/25/2000, 7:43 pm