Grant -- My 2 cents on both your questions. About a year ago, I asked the same question about a rotozip (guy at Sears was really pushing it). Responses on this borad were all negative. I purchased a DeWalt sabre saw ($100 @ Lowe's) and have been very pleased with it. Secondly, I built a Merganser last winter. It was my first boat, and I can not say enough good about it. I'm a new paddler and it's the only boat I've ever been in, but I love it. I'm 5-10 and 290#, so even the 17W is a tight fit. Good luck with whatever you decide to go with. -- Greg

: I've come down to Shearwater Merganser or CLC Northbay XL as likely
: candidates for my winter project. Has anyone paddled both? Strong opinions
: either way for firsttime builder? I know the answer might be both, but I
: need to start with one. 160#,5'10" athletic, but less than perfect
: roll.
: Thanks