Boat Building Forum

Find advice on all aspects of building your own kayak, canoe or any lightweight boats

While I do agree....
By:Kelly
Date: 2/3/2001, 11:51 am
In Response To: Looking for plans??? (Sam McFadden)

: Colin,

: Since it looks like nobody has stepped up to the soap box yet on this one, I
: will. Support the folks who make it possible for others to build boats
: without drawing the designs at home. Plans are inexpensive and books are
: too, especially when the total cost of the project is considered. If you
: buy a book for the plans, make sure it is a new copy so the author sees
: the return. The Cape Charles plans can be ordered off the CLC website.

: OK, I'm stepping down now.

I do not disagree with you in principle.Designers/creators deserve credit and financial remuneration for their toil.

I would like to, however, share my feelings/reactions to an experience I have had with one designer. Let me preface these comments with a short background. I attended university in Victoria, BC and often saw sea kayakers on the local waters, and I dreamed - of having the money and storage space, and a car to transport etc... Well, many years later with a family to support I happen upon this BBS, and after a few email contacts decide to take the plunge. I ordered three How-To books: one book on wood and canvas construction (Putz), one on strip-building (Schade), and the book mentioned in this thread.All three make the claim that using the books, one can build a complete kayak, and do it economically...To quote from the book in question in this thread, "...includes complete plans and instructions...anyone can build...".Then on p.19, we are informed that we "should invest in a full-size set of plans from the designer".

IF full-size plans are REQUIRED, THAT OUGHT TO BE MADE CLEAR, when one is buying the book.
The other two books mentioned here do, in fact, appear to fulfill the promises made.
Perhaps more care taken in what goes on the outside of a book will eliminate future 'misunderstandings'.

Kelly

Messages In This Thread

Looking for plans!!!
Colin Chaloux -- 2/2/2001, 12:14 pm
Re: "Free" Plans and Free Lunch
Geo. Cushing -- 2/8/2001, 10:49 am
Re: Looking for plans!!!
Mark Widrick -- 2/5/2001, 3:23 pm
Re: Looking for plans!!!
Rod Estvan -- 2/6/2001, 9:00 pm
Looking for plans???
Sam McFadden -- 2/2/2001, 7:56 pm
While I do agree....
Kelly -- 2/3/2001, 11:51 am
to confuse the issue even more . . .
Paul G. Jacobson -- 2/5/2001, 11:56 pm
Re: to confuse -Careful what U wish for...
John B. -- 2/6/2001, 7:47 pm
Re: Chill . . .
Spidey -- 2/5/2001, 1:43 am
I'll second Russ on this one
Mike Scarborough -- 2/3/2001, 5:53 pm
Re: I'll second Russ on this one
Kelly -- 2/4/2001, 9:50 am
Am I missing something?
Pete Rudie -- 2/4/2001, 12:11 pm
Re: I'll second Russ on this one
John Monfoe -- 2/4/2001, 4:35 am
chair in your shop
Angela Watson -- 2/3/2001, 6:25 pm
Re: chair in your shop
Mike Scarborough -- 2/3/2001, 7:57 pm
Re: chair in your shop
George Cushing -- 2/3/2001, 11:02 pm
Barking up the wrong tree
Russ -- 2/3/2001, 3:08 pm
Re: Norsky Barking Badly
Russ -- 2/5/2001, 8:47 am
I wonder if Colin...
Marcelo -- 2/5/2001, 1:42 pm
another consideration
Julie Kanarr -- 2/5/2001, 12:03 pm
Re: another consideration
Arlen -- 2/5/2001, 3:22 pm
Re: Barking up the wrong tree
Kelly -- 2/4/2001, 9:49 am
Re: Looking for plans???
Ross Sieber -- 2/3/2001, 6:05 am
Third world alternative
Marcelo -- 2/2/2001, 3:50 pm
I guess Chris' book have them for free...
Marcelo -- 2/2/2001, 1:25 pm
Re: I guess Chris' book have them for free...
Erez -- 2/2/2001, 3:43 pm
Re: I guess Chris' book have them for free...
Bruce Schultz -- 2/5/2001, 9:26 am
Plans in "The Kayak Shop"
Mike Scarborough -- 2/2/2001, 7:47 pm
Re: I guess Chris' book have them for free...
Jerry Petersen -- 2/2/2001, 3:41 pm