Boat Building Forum

Find advice on all aspects of building your own kayak, canoe or any lightweight boats

More Sensless george bashing
By:John Doerter
Date: 3/29/2001, 2:51 pm
In Response To: Re: I smell a coward (Bruce H.)

: George, at least have the guts to admit what you wrote....after all, its
: there for everyone to see.....

Interesting point what he did write was

>Maybe I missed something here.
>
>If I change the date on my computer, edit your test data file, and
>print the data file, I can support my claim of what was there. Your
>claim has as little merit as mine.
>
>For several years I have had on my web site an analysis of composite
>panels in bending. That analysis gives proper due to the strength of
>both the core and the facings. I got that stuff out of books 30 years
>old. Yet you make a claim of being first. I don't even make that claim.
>
>Now you make a claim that I did a faulty analysis of drag data
>presented by another and say I should make note of him. I did a simple
>flat plate analysis 3 years ago. It was based on airplane rudder
>procedures of 50 years ago. The drag data provided nice support on this
>board for my analysis. The comments I posted on the Design board did not
>rely on the test data.

: lest you need to be reminded, you wrote in response to Sams post
: regarding the data being available for all to see: George, you
: are pathetic....

As you can see the data posted was not attacked. Only Sams claim that
an alleged date on supposed piece of paper is proof, and George said
that hid past posts were not refrencing this data. Why don't you post
an public apology to George? I feel you should because either you

A) Failed to set aside your bias and read what he actually wrote or

B) Have intentionally misrepresented his post.
To top that off you added personal insult into a thread that had no
need of it. Perhaps you should take GR's suspension to heart. If
one read only this thread (yes i know he has been abrassive and abusive
in others) then you would have to admit that he has been on his best
behavior, yet people like you insist on personally insulting him.

Who is the coward? The one who tries to clear his name rationally, or
the person who posts falsehood and insults against some warned to keep
his posts clean.
John

Messages In This Thread

Re: I smell a coward
Bruce H. -- 3/26/2001, 7:40 pm
More Sensless george bashing
John Doerter -- 3/29/2001, 2:51 pm
Re: More Sensless george bashing
Bruce -- 3/29/2001, 3:39 pm