: I need help deciding which one. Having read many posts on this board and
: paddled a few I’ve narrowed it down to just ???? One thing missing from
: the posts on this site is how these yaks handle. I think builders are just
: so thrilled once they’ve finished that the bottom line is–my God, it
: floats!! While realizing that no one boat is better than another, I am
: interested in the handling characteristics of any of these kayaks – based
: on tracking, turning, and stability in big water. (I’m 5’6, 1651bs): 1)
: Laughing Loon “North Star” (is there really a problem with the plans re:
: fairing)
: 2) Jay Babina “Outer Island”
: 3) One Ocean Kayaks “Cape Ann Storm”
: 4) Guillemot “Expedition”
: My original choice was between the Guillemot and Night Heron, but after brief
: paddles in these beautiful boats, I felt they were poor trackers (how
: about installing a skeg). Having paddled for only a year, I am still
: learning basic stuff but first thing I did once deciding on the sport was
: buy a plastic Capella—based entirely on user reviews. I’m happy with the
: choice, it’s a great yak but is a terrible tracker, unless the skeg is
: deployed. I only mention this because the relationship of sea conditions
: and the handling characteristics of the kayak seems the principal factor
: in the choice. One characteristic of kayaks I don’t understand is their
: ability to either punch through waves or ride on them. Eg, the North Star
: is said to be high volume and rides over waves. What I would like to know
: is: is this actually an advantage in rough seas, or is a Greenlander style
: much more suited to swells/breaking waves? Is it preferable to punch
: through waves rather than over them, assuming you don’t want to surf? My
: paddling water is the Hudson and New England coast. Thanks for your input.

I think that your #3 and 4 choices are probably too large a boat for you in terms of your size vs. designer intent. The Outer Island is a nice boat as are some of the smaller sized One Ocean kayaks though!

Also consider the Redfish line of kayaks. I think the Silver is your size. FWIW, I'm working on a Return now but I'm about 50 lbs heavier than you.

Pete czerpak
albany, NY