Boat Building Forum

Find advice on all aspects of building your own kayak, canoe or any lightweight boats

Re: cedar boards
By:Bob Kelim
Date: 10/25/2001, 9:08 pm
In Response To: cedar boards (Paul G. Jacobson)

: Almost any lumberyard should have some cedar and redwood, but I think your
: problem is that you are looking for a very expensive grade: Clear.

: Why?

: Just last night I found some notes about the cedar I bought for my canoe. I
: got it at the local Builders Square (now out of business). The boat was
: only 14 1/2 feet long, so I only shopped for boards up to 16 feet. 5/4 x 6
: cedar for outdoor decks was the material I chose. It was graded as select
: S4S. In 16 foot lengths the store was asking $14.30 a board. They had
: shorter lengths too, of course, and as I was trying to economize I
: compared the price per boardfoot for each length and found that the 10
: foot lengths at $6.70 each were the most economical.

: The price I calculated per boardfoot was $1.38, and now that I think on it,
: the wood was probably 20% to 25% less than that. 5/4 lumber is an inch
: thick, so I figured 2 running feet of 5/4 x 6 to a boardfoot. But probably
: I should have figured that a boardfoot is 2 running feet of 1x6 stock.
: Since a 1x6 is actually only 3/4 inches thick, I got 1/4 inch more wood
: for my money. Even the 16 foot boards were reasonable, costing about $1.78
: per boardfoot (or maybe I should say "nominal square foot")

: I got knots.

: Some of them were big and some were tiny. Some of my strips were totally
: clear and a few broke into three pieces -- right at the substantial knots.
: I cut those off square and used them -- it looks like clear wood. The tiny
: knots are no more visible than the staple holes, but they influence the
: grain that swirls around them and add some pleasant texture and color to
: the wood. It looks like wood, not plastic. Half of the knots turned into
: sawdust as I ripped the strips.

: I think you would be happy with a lower grade of wood than "clear".
: Clear grade wood is easily twice the price of what I used, and if you want
: longer lengths, I think you might be looking at over $6 a board foot --
: over 4 times what I paid. Above that you will probably have to pay
: shipping for a special order.

: If you find wood with a tight grain and even color, a cheaper grade will be
: more cost effective. With the difference in price you can afford to buy an
: extra board or two (or many more) and give yourself more strips to chose
: from. The best ones go on the boat,and you can save your worst strips for
: stirring paint. If you plan to make bead and cove edges, the ugly strips
: are the ones you use (and waste) to set up the router.

: Of course butt joints and scarfs can be used to create longer pieces of
: "clear" strips, too. These joints are less noticeable if the
: wood color matches, or is close. Care in handling your strips after you
: cut them will allow you to join sections of strips that were cut
: sequentially. These strips will have the best grain and color match, and
: joints between them will look great.

: Hope this helps.

: PGJ
I used 1x6x6 fencing material for my 18 1/2' canoe. When I explained what I was doing and what I needed the yardman helped me go through their stock. My total cost for cedar in this boat is under $40.00
Bob

Messages In This Thread

Sources for WRC or Redwood (Iowa, Minnesota)
Richard Johnson -- 10/25/2001, 1:20 pm
Re: Sources for WRC or Redwood (Iowa, Minnesota)
Bryan Hansel -- 10/28/2001, 10:46 am
Re: Sources for WRC or Redwood (Iowa, Minnesota)
mike arnopol -- 10/27/2001, 2:27 am
Re: Sources for WRC or Redwood (Iowa, Minnesota)
Dan Lindberg -- 10/26/2001, 1:31 pm
Re: Sources for WRC or Redwood (Iowa, Minnesota)
Richard Johnson -- 10/26/2001, 2:15 pm
Re: Sources for WRC or Redwood (Iowa, Minnesota)
Dan Lindberg -- 10/31/2001, 2:11 pm
Re: Correction
Dan Lindberg -- 10/26/2001, 1:39 pm
Re: Sources for WRC or Redwood (Iowa, Minnesota)
John Monfoe -- 10/26/2001, 6:03 am
Re: Sources for WRC or Redwood (Iowa, Minnesota)
Pamela Watson -- 10/25/2001, 10:29 pm
cedar boards
Paul G. Jacobson -- 10/25/2001, 8:51 pm
Re: cedar boards
Richard Johnson -- 10/26/2001, 9:02 am
Tell ya what
Paul G. Jacobson -- 10/26/2001, 10:06 pm
Re: Tell ya what
Richard Johnson -- 10/29/2001, 3:21 pm
Re: Tell ya what
Don Beale -- 10/30/2001, 12:20 pm
Re: Tell ya what
Paul G. Jacobson -- 10/29/2001, 9:50 pm
Re: Tell ya what
Richard Johnson -- 10/30/2001, 11:07 am
Re: cedar boards
Bob Kelim -- 10/25/2001, 9:08 pm
Re: cedar boards
steve hartmann -- 10/25/2001, 10:05 pm
say the magic word and the duck gives you . . .
Paul G. Jacobson -- 10/26/2001, 5:00 pm
Re: say the magic word and the duck gives you . .
steve hartmann -- 10/26/2001, 7:53 pm
Re: say the magic word and the duck gives you . .
Julie Kanarr -- 10/26/2001, 8:18 pm
Re: Sources for WRC or Redwood (Iowa, Minnesota)
Jim Eisenmenger -- 10/25/2001, 5:48 pm
Re: Sources for WRC or Redwood (Iowa, Minnesota)
Rich D -- 10/25/2001, 2:05 pm