Boat Building Forum

Find advice on all aspects of building your own kayak, canoe or any lightweight boats

Re: Reviewers don't know more than you do!
By:LeeG
Date: 12/28/2002, 7:37 am
In Response To: Reviewers don't know more than you do! (Jay Babina)

: So much of our opinion about what kind of kayak traits we like is very
: personal.

You got that right . With these simple boats everything from outfitting to paddler skill and conditions can skew a one sentence description of an essential element.

There was such a sense of relief when the CLC 14 was reviewed in SK, I was the guy rushing to outfit it,filing off the protruding nail points that missed the sheer clamp, because I was sure the reviewers, one adult and a bunch of 'experienced' kids, would pick up on the adult sized coaming for a small persons boat that resulted in a very splayed out leg position, like what will happen in a Coho without thigh braces projecting into the cockpit. Especially relieved considering that no one actually got into it and paddled it before the design was committed to sale,,hmm maybe designing a racing kayak without a racer in the loop would work too? Kind of makes one a little more forgiving AND intolerant of the production designs in polyethelene and fiberglass. So anyone else have opinions on Perceptions use of back band adjustments that intrude into the cockpit?

Messages In This Thread

Other: Magazine reviews missing? *LINK*
Roger Nuffer -- 12/21/2002, 6:57 pm
Re: it's our playground
LeeG -- 12/28/2002, 7:06 am
Re: Other: Magazine reviews missing? *LINK*
Mike Hanks -- 12/22/2002, 2:01 am
maybe someone should invite their reviewers to..
Paul G. Jacobson -- 12/23/2002, 8:04 pm
Reviewers don't know more than you do!
Jay Babina -- 12/24/2002, 1:03 pm
Re: Reviewers don't know more than you do!
LeeG -- 12/28/2002, 7:37 am
Lack of unfavorable reviews
Brian Nystrom -- 12/26/2002, 2:58 pm
Re: Reviewers don't know more than we do!
Shawn Baker -- 12/24/2002, 1:44 pm
Review of Seakayaker mag?
martin -- 12/26/2002, 5:03 am
Re: Review of Seakayaker mag?
Shawn Baker -- 12/26/2002, 11:25 am