Date: 10/27/2003, 1:45 pm
Looking at wood density (i.e. specific gravity) figures at the link below, it depends on what species of pine you are using. Pine species range from .35 to .59. That's a large range. For comparison, WRC is .32. If 20 lbs of my 39 lb boat (Redfish Silver) is the cedar hull, then a pine hull could weigh anywhere from 24 to 37 pounds yielding a finished boat in the range of 43 to 56 pounds. There are other considerations of course. Pine is stronger, so you could make the strips thinner. But I don't know how well this would work in practice if the wood is more prone to splitting, pitch pocket problems, etc. I do know that WRC is wonderful stuff to work with and using it will make the project go easier (than using a more problematic wood species) and probably look better too.
Ted
: Where I live, I have a hard time finding cedar boards that are relatively
: free of knots, but knot-free pine boards are much easier to find, and much
: cheaper. I know that pine is heavier than cedar, but is that small weight
: difference enough to make a difference after the boat is finished? In
: other words, how much of the total weight of the boat comes from the wood
: itself? Also, are there any other significant differences between cedar
: and pine that I am overlooking? Thanks for your input.
Messages In This Thread
- Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar
Chris -- 10/27/2003, 11:22 am- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar *LINK* *Pic*
Andy Waddington -- 10/31/2003, 4:17 am- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar
rnb4tla -- 10/27/2003, 6:38 pm- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar
dominic -- 10/28/2003, 7:17 am
- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar
Bruce -- 10/27/2003, 4:15 pm- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar
C. Fronzek -- 10/27/2003, 2:35 pm- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar *LINK*
Ted Henry -- 10/27/2003, 1:45 pm- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar *Pic*
Kyle T -- 10/27/2003, 1:22 pm- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar
KenC -- 10/27/2003, 4:41 pm- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar *LINK* *Pic*
Kyle T -- 10/28/2003, 10:02 am
- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar *LINK* *Pic*
- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar
Chip Sandresky -- 10/27/2003, 12:31 pm- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar
Malcolm Schweizer -- 10/27/2003, 12:03 pm- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar
Ken -- 10/27/2003, 11:53 am - Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar
- Re: Strip: Pine v.s. Cedar *LINK* *Pic*