Date: 5/27/2010, 4:54 pm
The SawStop has been around - and much discussed - for years, with both supporters and detractors .
My concern? It was interesting to see the developer put his own finger to the test, but I don't find it a realistic enough test. He approached the side of the blade, without holding a piece of wood, at a verrrry slow, controlled rate of speed. The narrator says "... a finger being shoved through a tablesaw..." Shoved through? Hardly.
We've seen numerous frankfurters being nicked in controlled tests, and there are testimonials from satisfied users, but I remain skeptical. The forward momentum (if that's the right word) developed when actually cutting wood at a feed rate of several inches per second, without planning on stopping (as I can't help but think was on his mind in the video) sure seems to me would result in a significantly different outcome. I'm not saying amputation, but definitely more than the claimed "buzz or tickle!"
Brian mentioned the "first false activation," I worry more about the first failure *to* activate. BP assured us that all the safeguards were all in place in the Gulf last month; "nothing could go wrong." This raises another concern many have had about the SawStop, the false sense of security it engender in users. I won't go into that here, it's been addressed elsewhere.
Great concept, possibly a great product, but as one who's missing the tip of a finger and now has an overriding awareness of the inherent dangers around tablesaws and other fast-spinning woodworking tools, I'll stick with blade guards and total concentration on what I'm doing. I'm not saying it's the proper approach for everyone, I just know what feels right for me.
YMMV,
Glenn
Messages In This Thread
- Tools: Table saw safety device
PatrickC -- 5/27/2010, 9:32 am- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Mike -- 5/27/2010, 5:39 pm- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Mike Bielski -- 5/27/2010, 11:23 pm- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Will Clarke -- 5/27/2010, 11:57 pm- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Mike Bielski -- 5/28/2010, 1:11 am- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Brian Nystrom -- 5/28/2010, 7:29 am- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Mike Bielski -- 5/28/2010, 9:41 am
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Ken Blanton -- 5/27/2010, 4:11 pm- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Kurt Maurer -- 5/27/2010, 7:08 pm
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Brian Nystrom -- 5/27/2010, 10:15 am- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Paul MacIntyre -- 5/28/2010, 1:01 am- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Brian Nystrom -- 5/28/2010, 7:24 am- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Paul MacIntyre -- 5/28/2010, 8:42 am
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Paul MacIntyre -- 5/28/2010, 1:05 am - Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
PatrickC -- 5/27/2010, 10:35 am- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Glenn -- 5/27/2010, 4:54 pm- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Problem with the saw stop -- 5/29/2010, 7:12 pm- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Brian Nystrom -- 5/30/2010, 7:05 am- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
Jay Babina -- 5/30/2010, 8:03 am
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device *NM*
From Jay Babina - above -- 5/29/2010, 7:14 pm - Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device
- Re: Tools: Table saw safety device