Date: 2/9/2012, 3:51 pm
Previous post:
: I don't see why a lam should be any stiffer - or stronger - than an
: equivalent piece of solid wood. The glue has no tensile
: strength. But I agree about the extra hassle of laminating
: compared with steaming.
*******
: Hi,
: With laminating, the outer face of each piece is longer than the
: inner one when piece is curved and each face of laminates is
: held fixed to the one it's glued to. That prevents the layer
: from straightening, hence stiffer. It works for straight beams
: as well, many long wooden beams in construction are now
: laminated for that reason as well as it being more stable for
: the same reason.
: Most modern glues are actually stronger than the timber so cope
: with sheer stresses better than the wood.
: Hope this helps
: Mike Savage
: South West Cork
Mike is correct about the 'strength/stiffness' issue.
I have used both laminated (two layers only, over a curved form, glued with epoxy) and solid(heat-bent) sides in acoustic guitars.
At the same thickness, the laminated side is much, much stiffer than the heat-bent side.
For thicker curved beams (too thick to bend? masik?) a laminated beam will always be stronger than a sawn one with short grain, or a steam-bent beam. Of course, in a kayak the thicker deck beams aren't near their breaking point, I think.
Steam-bent frames in sailboats have provided steady work for restorers/repairers for years, laminated beams: not so much.
For SOF boats, steam-bending has the advantage of speed over making many laminating forms and I think it makes sense there.
Cheers
John
Messages In This Thread
- Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
stefalo -- 1/22/2012, 1:06 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Bill Hamm -- 1/22/2012, 3:07 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Bill Hamm -- 1/22/2012, 3:08 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
stefalo -- 1/22/2012, 3:16 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Bill Hamm -- 1/22/2012, 4:10 am
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Ken Blanton -- 1/22/2012, 6:04 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Matthias -- 1/22/2012, 7:14 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Dave Gentry -- 1/22/2012, 7:54 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Paul Montgomery -- 1/22/2012, 9:37 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Brian Nystrom -- 1/22/2012, 12:55 pm- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Paul Montgomery -- 1/22/2012, 8:02 pm
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Ken Blanton -- 1/22/2012, 5:51 pm- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Paul Montgomery -- 1/22/2012, 8:06 pm
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
- About the glue laming..
David Bynoe -- 1/22/2012, 7:08 pm- Re: About the glue laming..
Jeff Soper -- 2/5/2012, 1:13 am- Re: About the glue laming..
stefalo -- 2/8/2012, 11:09 pm- Re: About the glue laming..
Mike Savage -- 2/9/2012, 4:00 am
- Re: About the glue laming..
stefalo -- 2/9/2012, 12:18 am- Re: About the glue laming..
Jeff Soper -- 2/14/2012, 5:27 pm- Re: About the glue laming..
Bill Hamm -- 2/15/2012, 2:03 am- Re: About the glue laming..
Jeff Soper -- 2/20/2012, 9:50 pm- Re: About the glue laming..
Bill Hamm -- 2/26/2012, 3:47 am
- Re: About the glue laming..
- Re: About the glue laming..
- Re: About the glue laming..
- Re: About the glue laming..
ancient kayaker -- 2/9/2012, 10:55 am- Re: About the glue laming..
Mike Savage -- 2/9/2012, 2:23 pm- Re: About the glue laming..
John Abercrombie -- 2/9/2012, 3:51 pm- Re: About the glue laming..
ancient kayaker -- 2/9/2012, 10:12 pm- Re: About the glue laming..
Mike Savage -- 2/10/2012, 6:04 am
- Re: About the glue laming..
- Re: About the glue laming..
- Re: About the glue laming..
- Re: About the glue laming..
- Re: About the glue laming..
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder *PIC*
ancient kayaker -- 1/22/2012, 11:32 pm- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Bill Hamm -- 1/23/2012, 2:06 am
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Kent LeBoutillier -- 1/23/2012, 11:57 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
stefalo -- 1/23/2012, 5:39 pm- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Ken Blanton -- 1/23/2012, 9:58 pm- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Bill Hamm -- 1/24/2012, 2:35 am
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
ancient kayaker -- 1/24/2012, 12:21 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Matthias -- 1/24/2012, 2:21 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
ancient kayaker -- 1/25/2012, 12:55 am- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
stefalo -- 1/25/2012, 6:07 pm- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
ancient kayaker -- 1/25/2012, 10:28 pm
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
Ken Blanton -- 1/24/2012, 4:58 pm - Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder
- Re: Skin-on-Frame: First time builder